With how much everyone seemed to enjoy the pick 1 cigar for your 5 pack option, we decided to make that a permanent change to our Mystery 5 Packs. You will choose ONE (1) cigar from the list below that will be guaranteed to be in your 5 pack. The other 4 cigars will be a mix of cigars from the list below along with some other cigars we may have hiding in our humidors. Guaranteed to be a combined value at well over the $25 price tag. Plus, as always, free shipping! If you want it to be a total surprise, choose the Surprise Me option.